Together we are beating cancer

Donate now
  • Health & Medicine

Triple negative breast cancer drug given initial ‘no’ for NHS in England

The PA Media logo
by In collaboration with PA Media Group | News

8 April 2022

4 comments 4 comments

An image of a breast cancer cell taken with a scanning electron microscope
Image Credit:

Sacituzumab govitecan (Trodelvy) is not being recommended by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) for use in England as a treatment for some people with triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC).

Clinical trials reveal that the targeted treatment is proven to help treat aggressive TNBC in patients who have already had two previous therapies. However, the drug is not currently considered a cost-effective treatment for NHS England, according to NICE draft guidance. 

This decision will be disappointing for people affected by triple-negative breast cancer that’s spread locally or to other parts of the body, as there are currently very limited effective treatment options for these patients.

Rose Gray, head of policy development at Cancer Research UK. 

An aggressive breast cancer 

There are an estimated 2,000 people living with TNBC in England. However, despite only accounting for 15% of all breast cancer cases, TNBC is responsible for a quarter of all deaths from breast cancer in England, making it a particularly aggressive form of the disease.  

TNBC does not have any of the three molecular markers (oestrogen, progesterone and HER2 receptors) commonly found in other types of breast cancer. Because TNBC is not sensitive to hormone therapy or molecular targeted therapy, this significantly reduced treatment options and prognosis for patients, with chemotherapy being the main form of treatment. 

New targeted treatment 

Sacituzumab govitecan could provide a new treatment option for people with TNBC who have already had two or more prior systemic therapies. 

The drug works by targeting the activity of Trop-2 proteins that are present at high levels on the surface of tumour cells. It then delivers the anti-cancer component of the drug directly to tumour cells, preventing the cells from multiplying and eventually causing them to die. 

A randomised open label clinical trial involving 468 eligible patients confirmed that people treated with sacituzumab govitecan had a longer period of time before their cancer grew compared to the physician’s chemotherapy of choice. Those given sacituzumab govitecan lived for an average of 11.8 months, compared to 6.9 months in the treatment of physician’s choice arm. 

Additionally, the percentage of patients whose tumours shrunk was greater in the group who received sacituzumab govitecan at 31.1%, compared with 4.2% in the treatment of physician’s choice arm. 

Of the 2,000 people in England with TNBC, around 650 would have been eligible for treatment with sacituzumab govitecan if the drug was recommended by NICE. 

NICE say no to sacituzumab govitecan 

Despite its effectiveness, draft guidance by NICE does not recommended sacituzumab govitecan for use on NHS England due to its high cost. An alternative treatment recommended by NICE is a type of immunotherapy known as atezolizumab (Tecentriq) in combination with chemotherapy. 

“Because sacituzumab govitecan is a highly effective treatment, and given the lack of treatment options for people with this type of breast cancer, we’re very disappointed that its price means we can’t recommend it for use in the NHS at this point.   

“We hope that the company will consider what it can do to enable NICE to approve a treatment that has the potential to give people with advanced triple negative breast cancer more time with their loved ones,” says Helen Knight, interim director of medicines evaluation at NICE.   

“We recognise that the time and cost it takes to develop a new medicine means cancer drugs can often come with high price tags and we urge the NHS and drug companies to consider long-term solutions to this. Drug prices should ensure value for money for the NHS while also rewarding companies for innovative treatments that benefit cancer patients,” adds Gray. 

The draft guidance is available for public consultation until 29 April 2022. A final decision is expected to be made by June 2022. 

NICE decisions are usually adopted in Wales and Northern Ireland as well as England, so the decision is likely to affect patients in all 3 nations, however the drug was approved by the Scottish Medicines Consortium (SMC) for use in Scotland last month. 


    Comments

  • Kay
    7 July 2022

    Medications should be cheaper.
    Big pharma already making TONS of money

  • Susie
    26 April 2022

    I hope they change their mind. It is so hard to put a price on a loved ones life.

  • Belinda davies
    22 April 2022

    Hope they change their mind as this could have a massive affect for women with this disease

  • Shannon Draisey
    21 April 2022

    What a terrible decision! This should be made available on the NHS. How can we support this cause?

  • reply
    Jacob Smith
    21 April 2022

    Hi Shannon,

    Breast Cancer Now are running a campaign encouraging people to sign an open letter calling on the pharmaceutical company Gilead, NICE and NHS England to find a solution that will make Trodelvy available to the patients who need it. You can access the campaign through this link: Time for Trodelvy

    Jacob

    Comments

  • Kay
    7 July 2022

    Medications should be cheaper.
    Big pharma already making TONS of money

  • Susie
    26 April 2022

    I hope they change their mind. It is so hard to put a price on a loved ones life.

  • Belinda davies
    22 April 2022

    Hope they change their mind as this could have a massive affect for women with this disease

  • Shannon Draisey
    21 April 2022

    What a terrible decision! This should be made available on the NHS. How can we support this cause?

  • reply
    Jacob Smith
    21 April 2022

    Hi Shannon,

    Breast Cancer Now are running a campaign encouraging people to sign an open letter calling on the pharmaceutical company Gilead, NICE and NHS England to find a solution that will make Trodelvy available to the patients who need it. You can access the campaign through this link: Time for Trodelvy

    Jacob