Skip to main content

Together we are beating cancer

Donate now
  • Health & Medicine

Main carrot energy: how vegetables became the stars of our plates

by Julia Cotterill | In depth

19 January 2026

3 comments 3 comments

A grid of pictures of vegetables with stick on googly eyes and smiles against colourful backgrounds.
Davizro Photography/Shutterstock.com

Vegetables definitely play a leading role in a healthy balanced diet. After all, they’re packed with nutrients, low in calories and a source of fibre. They can help with keeping a healthy weight, which reduces the risk of 13 different types of cancer, and a diet with plenty of fibre helps to reduce the risk of bowel cancer too. As if that weren’t enough, eating plants is good for the planet as well.

But did you know that veggies’ star quality wasn’t always recognised? In this article, we’re going to follow their journey to stardom and share some facts and tips along the way.

Before they were famousĀ 

Any star needs a backstory. It took a while for veggies to be ā€˜discovered’ and catapulted into the limelight. Before the discovery of vitamins and minerals, we couldn’t fully appreciate the benefits of eating veg.

For example, an influentialĀ 19th century US scientist at Wesleyan University, Wilbur Olin Atwater, believed that the most important thing about food was how many calories it provided. He called this the ā€œfuel valueā€. Though he recognised that foods contained different ā€œmineral mattersā€, like the rest of the scientific community at the time, he didn’t realise their significance. He thought it was all about protein, carbohydrates and fat.

Atwater carried out experiments in which people spent days in a special chamber, so he could measure their energy intake and output. ā€œFood and drink are passed into the chamber through an aperture which serves also for the removal of the solid and liquid excretory products,ā€ he wrote. Apparently, a Dr Towne ā€œrather enjoyed his stay in the chamberā€ – maybe there wasn’t much to do in Connecticut at the time.

An old black and white picture showing a man in a suit stepping out of a sealed chamber onto a small platform. He is surrounded by tubing and old scientific equipment.
A test subject emerges after a stay in Atwater's special chamber. Courtesy of Special Collections, U.S. National Agricultural Library

AtwaterĀ used his findings toĀ put together a sort of league tableĀ of foods based on their fuel value.Ā AnyoneĀ using that as a guide to what they should be eating would end up eating a lot of meat, drinkingĀ alcoholĀ andĀ not really bothering withĀ vegetables.Ā Of course,Ā we know nowĀ that, as well as eating more veg,Ā it’sĀ also important toĀ cut down on processed and red meatĀ toĀ reduce the risk of bowel cancer.Ā Despite his findings,Ā AtwaterĀ wasĀ against drinking alcohol andĀ wouldĀ probably beĀ pleased to hear that, if you drink alcohol,Ā cutting down reduces your risk of 7 types of cancer.

Always learning

While Atwater’s fuel value theoryĀ wasn’tĀ accurate, he did recognise something important: not everyone had equal access to a healthy diet. He noted thatĀ ā€œmany whose means are limited … are often inadequately nourished when they might be well fed at less cost.ā€Ā AtwaterĀ thought the problem was that people didn’t know which foods were healthiest and hoped that his research would help them choose foods that were both nutritious and affordable.

Although our understanding of nutrition has moved on since Atwater’s day,Ā inequalities in diet are still with us.Ā That’sĀ linked to theĀ factĀ thatĀ eating healthily is about moreĀ than knowingĀ whatĀ to eat.Ā ItĀ takes time,Ā moneyĀ and energy to buy, store and prepare healthy food,Ā andĀ healthier options cost more than twice as much per calorie as less healthy ones.Ā Then there’s the wayĀ unhealthy food isĀ advertisedĀ and promoted, whichĀ canĀ alsoĀ affect some groups more than others.

That’sĀ whyĀ we’reĀ calling on governments across the UK to make it easier for everyone to be healthy.Ā Though the path to policy change is rarely straightforward,Ā we’reĀ making progress.Ā NewĀ promotion and advertising restrictionsĀ are takingĀ unhealthy food out of the spotlight andĀ creatingĀ healthier shopping journeys for consumers.

ButĀ more needs to be done toĀ help make it easier for everyone toĀ eat more healthily. UK and devolved governmentsĀ need to keep upĀ theĀ momentum andĀ focus onĀ creatingĀ healthier environments for everyone, including through actions to reduce diet-related inequalities.

Getting discoveredĀ 

Lots of stars have a story of overcoming challenges to get to where they are. Having their book rejected, being dropped by their record label, not getting the role that seemed perfect for them. And vegetables faced an even bigger obstacle – society didn’t recognise the existence of a key part of what they had to offer.

The discovery of vitamins and mineralsĀ didn’tĀ start until around the beginning of the 20thĀ century.Ā Before then, althoughĀ some illnesses such asĀ beriberi (vitamin B1Ā deficiency)Ā were known to beĀ linked toĀ the absence of something from the diet,Ā doctors and scientists had no idea whatĀ it was.Ā No wonder veggies were overlookedĀ and left in nutritional obscurity.

Long before Dr Towne enjoyed the exceptional room service in Atwater’s chamber, vitamins were being overlooked with fatal consequences. Dr James Lind, in his Treatise on Scurvy, published in 1753, noted that ā€œ[a]rmies have been supposed to lose more of their men by sickness than by the sword.ā€ In what is often said to be the world’s first randomised trial, Lind ā€œtook twelve patients in the scurvyā€ and gave them different possible treatments, including ā€œtwo oranges and one lemon … every dayā€.

Although he concluded that ā€œoranges and lemons were the most effectual remedies for this distemper at sea,ā€ Lind still refused to accept that scurvy was caused solely by dietary deficiency and insisted that it was due to ā€œan obstructed perspiration.ā€ It would be another 42 years before the Admiralty ordered the provision of lemon juice to sailors, and vitamin C itself wasn’t discovered until 1928. This, and the discovery of other vitamins and minerals around the same time, put veg on the path to stardom and showed the importance of eating a variety of them.

Today, scientists are exploring how vitaminsĀ andĀ minerals might be able to help with cancer treatment too.

Becoming an influencerĀ 

As a star onĀ the rise following the discovery of vitamins early in the 20th century,Ā oneĀ vegĀ entered anĀ unusualĀ promotional partnership during World War II.

You’ve probably heard that carrots will help you see in the dark, but is it true? Well, yes and no. Like other red, green (leafy) and yellow veg like spinach, red peppers and sweet potatoes, carrots are a good source of a pigment called beta-carotene. Our bodies convert it to vitamin A, which helps us to see in dim light. So, although there is a connection between carrots and night vision, as long as we’re getting enough vitamin A (which we can also get from eggs and dairy), carrots in our diet won’t make our night vision any better.

whole: the image is placed left with the text, in black and orange, positioned right, set within a irregular yellow inset. All is set against a green background. image: 'Dr Carrot', a bright orange bespectacled carrot, skips left to right carrying a top hat and a doctor's briefcase marked 'Vit- A'. text: DOCTOR CARROT the Children's best friend
Carrots are easy to grow in gardens, so, during wartime rationing, the Ministry of Food created Dr Carrot to encourage children to eat more of them. Image: IWM (Art.IWM PST 8105)

So, why the hypeĀ about carrots and eyesight?Ā The story goes that,Ā toĀ keepĀ a new type ofĀ radarĀ secret, the British governmentĀ launched a propaganda campaignĀ claimingĀ that pilotsĀ were eating lots of carrots to boost theirĀ eyesight.Ā It’sĀ not clearĀ whether that was in fact the intentionĀ or whether it succeeded in keeping radarĀ under wraps.Ā Either way,Ā 80 years laterĀ we’reĀ stillĀ sayingĀ carrots help to see in the dark.Ā CarrotsĀ can last a while in the fridgeĀ or freezer, butĀ stories aboutĀ themĀ last for decades.

You’ve probably read media stories about diet and health that include claims that particular foods that cause, prevent or ā€˜fight’ cancer. In reality, no single foodĀ or ingredient can prevent or ā€˜fight’ cancer.Ā What we eat day to day is more important for reducingĀ your cancer risk.

What about supplements?

There is no reliable evidence that supplements and multivitamins reduce the risk of cancer. Additionally, studies have shown that taking high doses of beta carotene through supplements may increase the risk of lung cancer in people who smoke.Ā 

Most people should get all the nutrients they need by eating aĀ healthy balanced diet. Sometimes, a doctor may recommend certain vitamin and mineral supplements to treat a diagnosed medical condition or deficiency (a lack of a vitamin or nutrient).

We have separate information on vitamins and diet supplements for people affected by cancer.

Great collaborations

Each vegetable brings its own combination of nutrients to the table,Ā so, like many stars,Ā they’reĀ great when theyĀ work together.Ā Filling half of your plate with veg or salad is a great start for a healthy balanced meal, especially if you eat a range of different veg.Ā It might feel easier to think about adding veg than to focus on foodsĀ you’reĀ trying to eat less of.Ā 

You canĀ alsoĀ swap inĀ beans and pulses like lentils, soybeans (including tofu) and chickpeas or egusi (ground melon seeds) for veggie protein if you’re trying to cut down on processed and red meat. And starchy veg like potatoes and plantains are a source of carbohydrates which give us energy – keep the skin on potatoes for a fibre boost too.Ā 

An infographic titled 'Healthy balanced meals'. On the left there is a top down view of a plate, and on the right there is a cross-section of a bowl. Both are divided into three sections to make a healthy balanced meal. The text underneath corresponds to these three divisions. It says

And veggiesĀ harmoniseĀ onĀ the stage, as well as the plate.Ā The bottle gourd, also known as the calabash, is used in cultures around the world to make percussion,Ā stringĀ and wind instruments.Ā There are alsoĀ entire orchestrasĀ who play instruments made from vegetables.Ā CRUK’s patron, King Charles, once played ā€˜Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star’ on aĀ recorder made from a carrot.Ā Get down to that beet!

JetĀ pakĀ choi

When you reach a certain level of stardom, it’s time for a trip to the stars. Scientists on board the International Space Station are researching plant growth in space. For now, crews can be sent prepackaged meals. But, for space missions further away, they’d need to be able to grow their own food.Ā One experiment withĀ pakĀ choi was so successful the astronaut who grew it was able to enjoy some as a side dish with soy sauce and garlic.

An image from the inside of the International Space Station. On the left are six lush green pak choi plants in planters. They are tied down with red wire to stop them floating away. On the right is Flight Engineer Soichi Noguchi in in a red t-shirt. He is smiling at the camera.
Flight Engineer Soichi Noguchi of the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency with Pak Choi plants growing aboard the International Space Station. Image courtesy of NASA.

Back on Earth,Ā fresh,Ā tinnedĀ or frozen veg all count towards our five a dayĀ and youĀ don’tĀ have to grow them yourself.Ā Although, if you want to, gardening isĀ a great wayĀ ofĀ building moreĀ exerciseĀ into your day.Ā Now, pass the soy sauce and garlic.

Household nameĀ 

Wilbur Olin Atwater thought that food’s value was measured in fuel. But it’s so much more than that. Stars become stars because we love what they do. Food is no different – we enjoy it, we share it with the people we care about and we even use it to express ourselves. Veggies do more than fuel and nourish our bodies – they’re part of our emotional, social and cultural lives. It’s time to roll out the red tablecloth and celebrate them.

Julia

    Comments

  • Anne Thomson
    22 January 2026

    Very interesting , sometimes incorrect info scares individuals from certain foods
    I am involved in a FOOD BANK and concerned that too much of what we are able to offer is highly processed , but pleased to hear that tinned vegetables can be a useful substitute .

  • Jane GIFFOULD
    21 January 2026

    Back in the 50s I was brought up with the importance of a balanced diet. My mum impressed on me the importance of the main meal being meat and 2 veg followed by something with fruit. If one insisted on fish and chips, then add peas and an apple. She was keen on a range of vitamins and minerals along with fibre being as part of the diet.

  • R H martin
    21 January 2026

    Relief! as having lost my wife , (and being 81 my appetite is not what it was) I find I can’t eat Veg & fruit quickly enough to stop it getting very “sad”. I have therefore taken to buying a mix of frozen fruits & Veg and cooking , or eating, these. I hope I get enough protein from pulses, grains, & mushroom meat substitutes. [Most days I do get over two miles of brisk walking] . Why “relief” your comment that tinned or Frozen veg all count, thanks for the reassurance!

Tell us what you think

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read our comment policy.

    Comments

  • Anne Thomson
    22 January 2026

    Very interesting , sometimes incorrect info scares individuals from certain foods
    I am involved in a FOOD BANK and concerned that too much of what we are able to offer is highly processed , but pleased to hear that tinned vegetables can be a useful substitute .

  • Jane GIFFOULD
    21 January 2026

    Back in the 50s I was brought up with the importance of a balanced diet. My mum impressed on me the importance of the main meal being meat and 2 veg followed by something with fruit. If one insisted on fish and chips, then add peas and an apple. She was keen on a range of vitamins and minerals along with fibre being as part of the diet.

  • R H martin
    21 January 2026

    Relief! as having lost my wife , (and being 81 my appetite is not what it was) I find I can’t eat Veg & fruit quickly enough to stop it getting very “sad”. I have therefore taken to buying a mix of frozen fruits & Veg and cooking , or eating, these. I hope I get enough protein from pulses, grains, & mushroom meat substitutes. [Most days I do get over two miles of brisk walking] . Why “relief” your comment that tinned or Frozen veg all count, thanks for the reassurance!

Tell us what you think

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read our comment policy.