“Our motivation for studying it is because there haven’t been any new effective treatments for decades.”
Overall, survival for children’s cancers in the UK has more than doubled since the 1970s. Today around 8 in 10 children diagnosed with cancer will survive. We have come a long way. But for some cancer types, progress has been stunted.
Professor Chris Jones, based at the Institute of Cancer Research (ICR), studies a type of brain tumour known as Diffuse Intrinsic Pontine Glioma (DIPG). DIPG occurs almost exclusively in children, when they’re about 6 to 8 years old.
“It’s found in the brainstem and because of where it’s found, you can’t operate. Cutting the tumour out isn’t possible at all. So for that reason, and the fact they spread throughout the brainstem and the central nervous system, they’re essentially incurable.”
The average survival for a child diagnosed with this type of brain tumour is just 9 months. And because studying DIPG has its challenges, sadly this figure has shown little improvement over the years.
But the tide may slowly be turning.
Decades in the making
For decades, clinical trials of DIPG were based on work done using samples from adult brain tumours that looked similar to DIPG down a microscope. None of these studies were able to provide answers and because of the lack of actual DIPG samples, there was a gap in our understanding of the biology of the disease.
“It wasn’t until about 10 years ago that we started collecting biopsies in the clinic” explains Jones. And it’s this change in practice that’s led us to where we are today.
This surge in taking biopsies happened around the same time on both sides of the Atlantic. In Europe, namely Paris, researchers began introducing a minimally invasive form of surgery for biopsies. “And so from both Europe and the USA, we soon had a sufficient quantity and quality of material to start doing the molecular work that we’re building on now.”
The samples used by Jones came from the Biological Medicine for DIPG Eradication trial, known as the BIOMEDE trial. It’s a Europe-wide, phase 2 trial that started in Paris. The UK arm of the trial, co-funded by us and The Brain Tumour Charity, was led by Professor Darren Hargrave.
What researchers saw when they first studied the samples changed our understanding of DIPG.
“It’s unlike any other form of cancer, it’s completely different to the similar looking tumours that occur in elderly adults, driven by different genes, different pathways,” Jones explains. “So it was no wonder that all the trials that had been done for so many years failed, because although it looked similar down a microscope, the underlying biology was completely different.”
The samples have already proved invaluable, revealing that DIPG is totally biologically unique.
A promising discovery
The team began by testing drugs on tumour samples grown in the lab. A subset of cells seemed to be very responsive to a group of drugs known as MEK inhibitors, which block signals from a protein called MEK that tell cells to divide and grow.
But when they tested the MEK inhibitor trametinib in mice with DIPG, the effects fell short. Tumour cells quickly became resistant to the drug.
“It didn’t seem to work on its own, which got us thinking, what do we know about this drug and this pathway?”
While this class of drugs can be very effective in some tumour types, these cancers can develop resistance to them, through a number of mechanisms. So the team went back to the drawing board to try and figure out why the tumour cells were becoming resistant.
“When we began looking into the biology,” explains Jones, “they all came back with essentially the same mechanism.”
The cells were developing mutations in MEK. And with these small changes, they were no longer susceptible to the effects of the drugs.
Now the researchers had an idea of how the cancer cells were developing resistance to the MEK inhibitors, they were prepared to find a way to circumnavigate the resistance, by trialling different drug combinations.
The team went back to analyse their initial data and found that the samples that became resistant to MEK drugs were sensitive to one of the very first trial drugs used for the children with DIPG, dasatinib. “Essentially, if you’re resistant to one drug, you’re sensitive to the other and vice versa.”
Trametinib in combination with dasatinib managed to cut growth in mice with DIPG by over 60%.
“They have the potential to be a very promising combination in children with DIPG with this particular molecular signature.”
A catalyst for change
Jones emphasises that none of this would be possible without the advocacy of the parents.
“Imagine you get a terrible diagnosis like this and told your child isn’t going to make it. When parents asked what can be done, they were told nothing, because no one is studying it.”
The parent community was fundamental in catalysing this change, “partly through their advocacy and, opening up of samples, but also by funding it directly, and bringing researchers into the field and working together”.
As well as being co-funded by us, this particular project was funded by a number of cancer charities, including Christopher’s Smile, Abbie’s Army, Islastones Foundation, the CRIS Cancer Foundation, Children with Cancer UK, and the Ollie Young Foundation.
Abbie’s Army is a charity dedicated to raising awareness and funding for DIPG and providing practical support and guidance for families who have been affected by the disease.
It was founded in November 2012 after Abbie Mifsud passed away from DIPG, just 5 months after her diagnosis. The charity was set up by Abbie’s parents, Amanda and Ray, so that one day parents of children diagnosed with DIPG won’t have to go through what they did.
“When you are embedded in the DIPG ‘community’ as we are, this total lack of any clinical trials or a valid data driven treatment in the UK is a constant source of anger and frustration to parents,” says Amanda. “These children and their families have waited decades already and are desperate for new treatment opportunities.”
Abbie’s Army has raised vital funds for the research of DIPG, including Jones’ ground-breaking work.
“We firmly believe that the only way to lead development of effective treatment options for all children affected is by funding specific, targeted research initiatives that improve our understanding of exactly how DIPG develops and progresses.”
Amanda recognises the kind of impact these latest findings could have.
“There is definitely progress and our hope for DIPG families of the future is that with sufficient investment we can do much more to bridge the gap between what these families need and what is currently being offered.”
The benefit for patients
The samples we now have thanks to the BIOMEDE trial provide a valuable resource for researchers all over the world to continue making strides for DIPG. “If anybody wanted samples for more in depth, functional studies and other molecular studies that, it’s an enormous resource of the community to understand this disease in more detail.”
While, the novel combination showed great success in early trials in the lab, further research is still needed until we can see a real difference for patients.
Nevertheless, Jones is excited about what the future holds. “One of my PhD students, also funded by Cancer Research UK, is taking the research to the next stage, by looking at mathematical modelling of what the best treatment schedule would be.
“Eventually we hope to take our findings to a clinical trial, and show improvement in survival for these children, which we haven’t been able to show yet. The growing interest in the field has given me hope. I am really optimistic that between us all, we are going to start to see these results filtered through to benefits for the patients.”
Kinga March 18, 2022
Is mathematical modelling the fastest route to clinic? These children desperately need a lifeline and by spinning this out via CRT and getting accelerated approval, a suitable treatment plan could be found sooner in my opinion. Fantastic research here, FINALLY but we need to keep challenging the dogmas, because these young cancer patients cannot wait until tomorrow.
Russell Allen. March 15, 2022
Hi, to be told that your child has a disease that is inoperable has to be one of the worst diagnosis that a parent could hear especially in a child so young.
You can well imagine why the parent has been reluctant to donate their brain to medical research but for those that have done so, have to be applauded through every aspect of the research that that donation will provide .
Let’s hope that a more positive outcome will come as a result of further research.
Please keep trying.
Naomi March 15, 2022
Wonderful work,hope it achieves the goal.
Andrea Ghelani March 14, 2022
Such a frustratingly sad but uplifting article in one. Thank you for keeping us factually and honestly informed about this field of research. However, it also shows the huge importance of continuous funding and spurs us on to do more.
Penny Grover March 13, 2022
When studying childhood cancers, is the question: “why did the cancer start initially” ever asked?
If it has been asked then has anything been found?
Sarah Gallagher March 12, 2022
Very Important information regarding this research .Many thanks.
Sharon Foster March 12, 2022
Really interesting and inspiring to read of the innovative research. Thank you
Pauline March 12, 2022
So fantastic to read of all the research moving forward to help children.
Dawn Buckle March 11, 2022
It’s so interesting to read about specific research such as this to know how funding I give is being used for the benefit of children who develop this cancer.
Marge Glenn March 11, 2022
Impressed with all information and research, thank you
Cynthia Thejane March 11, 2022
May l have Prostate Cancer info in a booklet to refresh
Cynthia Thejane March 11, 2022
Such a detailed info, Much Appreciated, can I have it in a booklet by post
Shannon Draisey March 10, 2022
Far more progress needs to be made with brain cancer. Current treatment options are not good enough on the NHS or privately
pierre schembri-wismayer March 10, 2022
My son Keiran, aged 12 or so at the time, came up with i think the best way i have ever heard to try and tackle DIPG. Since it cannot be operated where it is, inject attractive cytokines into part of the brain where it can be operated, for example one of the lobes of the cerebellum…. wait till the cancer moves there and then operate.
Jacqueline M Brand March 9, 2022
Great that the scientific world is working in collaboration with their partners worldwide to improve and treat children and families suffering from the devastating diagnosis of a brain tumour. Although progress seems painfully slow for patients and families affected , I am reassured that by supporting Cancer Research, I am contributing to the scientists who are pioneering treatments and giving us hope for better outcomes in the future